That rather depends when they transitioned doesn’t it? A trans woman who used hormone blockers early and began using female hormone injections as soon as legally possible is not going to be comparable to a trans woman who transitioned later and was previously well-muscled.

One massive issue with all arguments of this kind is that those in the ‘anti’ camp will use generalised, sweeping and/or theoretical statements to ‘prove’ their case, while on the ‘pro’ side of things there are real, individual people with real lives of value and specific circumstances needing to be considered.

The anti-trans bandwagon dehumanises actual, vulnerable human beings using cherry picked, over blown and twisted ‘evidence’ for their claims. Don’t encourage them by trying to be ‘fair’.